Discussion: Bookish Opinions



So I’ve been seeing this Twitter thing going around in which you tweet one bookish opinion per like your tweet gets.  I have a LOT of opinions and 140 characters is just too short, so I thought I’d ask you guys to join in on the fun!

What are your bookish opinions, popular or otherwise?  What drives you crazy about the book community?  What underrepresented books do you want to see more of?  Do you have reading quirks?  Shout about them here!


Here are some of mine:

1) I am first and foremost a spine breaker and everyone else can just freaking deal with it. Have you ever tried to read a 1,000 page mass market paperback without cracking the spine or messing it up in any way?  I dare you to try.

I eat while I read.  I read in the tub.  I chuck my book in my purse and take it with me everywhere.  My books get messed up.  They get tattered.  They’re not always pretty and pristine when I am done with them, but they’re meant to be enjoyed and loved.



2) I absolutely love lending people books.  If someone wants to read one of my favourite books and I have a copy, it’s theirs. I am the Great Library of Justine.


3) Bookshelves arranged by colour are gorgeous, but so impractical.  I would probably know where everything was if I arranged my shelves like this, but everything would be split up!  What about the series?  I’m not sure I could deal with it.

My shelves actually aren’t arranged in any special way right now.  I just shove books where they fit and try to keep series together where I can.  I’d like to arrange them by genre or put them in alphabetical order, but honestly I acquire so many books that I’d be constantly reshuffling things to make them all fit!



4) No one should ever, ever, be shamed for what they’re reading.  I’ve been seeing a few younger bloggers complaining that adults are getting ARC’s of YA books when they, the teen bloggers, are ‘entitled’ to such things.  No.  Anyone should be able to read whatever they want.  If you’re an adult who reads YA, awesome!  Prefer sci-fi and fantasy?  Great!  Read romance?  That’s fantastic.

The one that bothers me most is romance.  Romance readers are the butt of so many jokes.  I was at Bloody Scotland last year and the two of the three authors at a particular event randomly decided to go on a rampage against romance authors and readers.  Seriously?  You’re in an auditorium of 200+ people who you’d ideally like to buy your book.  You’re going to potentially trash their reading taste?  I can guarantee that I’ll never buy either of your books. The same goes for authors who try to trash other authors or genres (cough cough Phillipa Gregory cough.  Never buying one of your books.  Byeee.)

Romance outsells every other genre by a huge margin. Romance novels make it possible to fund a number of other books a publisher produces from the risky debut author to the small-run literary fiction.

Okay, I’m done with that rant.  This makes me mad.

Angry me


5) Similarly, if you preach about how people should take your genre seriously while making fun of or looking down on readers of other genres, you’re part of the problem.


6) The most popular opinion of all: libraries are wonderful and you should use them.

Slightly weird opinion: I must own my books.  If I get something from the library and love it, I end up needing to buy it.



7) The number of books you read does not reflect how ‘good’ or ‘bad’ of a reader you are. Read at your own pace, read for yourself, and never feel bad for not reading as much as another person.

I feel like the blogging community unintentionally sets us up for feeling guilt about the amount we read.  I see people who get through 10-20 books a month, sometimes even more, and I wonder why the hell I can’t read that much!  But I shouldn’t care, and I’m working on getting better about this.



8) Everyone should try classics, BUT don’t feel like you’re a bad reader for not liking them.  So much emphasis is put on how many classic books you have read, and I’m not sure that’s a good thing.  I think there’s something out there for everyone in terms of classics (I can make suggestions if you want one!) and it’s important to see where our favourite genres grew from.  But if you don’t enjoy them, then you don’t enjoy them.  And that’s okay!


9) DNF books!  Chuck them over your shoulder dramatically if you don’t like them!  Life is too short to read books you’re not enjoying.  Just because one person loved a book doesn’t mean you will.  Similarly, just because you hated a book does not make it ‘bad’.  I give a book 100 pages to grab my interest.  If I don’t like it, I put it aside.  As a reader, I have no obligation to finish a book I don’t enjoy.

My favourite gif of all time


10) We should be able to discuss why we disliked a popular book without fans of said book jumping down our throats.  It’s okay to dislike something that’s popular.  I have absolutely hated some popular books and I do worry that I’ll get attacked for it.


11) I think that it’s not a good thing to only read one kind of book.  Whether it’s an age range (only adult or only young adult) or a genre (only fantasy), you’re narrowing your mindset.  It’s good to branch out and read something new from time to time.  Now, I’m not saying you have to abandon your beloved fantasy for literary fiction, but I do think that readers should try out new things.  Who knows, you may discover something new that you absolutely love!

Also, branching out helps prevent reading slumps.




Those are my bookish opinions!  I have a lot more (I am very grumpy and opinionated), but I’ll stop for now.  Now it’s your turn.

Let’s chat!  What are your bookish opinions?  Do you agree with any of these?  Disagree?  What have your experiences been?  Let me know, I’d love to discuss!


20 thoughts on “Discussion: Bookish Opinions

  1. Judging people on what genre they read is one of my pet hates! I’m the same with how many books I can read in a month, and what classics I’ve read. I feel like the people who manage 10 books in a month are ‘better readers’ than me, even though I have piles of work to do on the side (I’m in my final year of uni!) As for the classics, it goes back to judging people on their taste in books. If you don’t enjoy reading classics, don’t read them! You should fill your reading time with books you enjoy, and not books everyone else expects you to read! A wonderful discussion post, thank you ☺️

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Isn’t it just the worst thing? I am always so shocked when I see readers making fun of other readers.

      I love classics, but I don’t expect other people to love them as much as I do! I think it’s unfair to judge someone as ‘well read’ by the number of ‘classic’ books they’ve read. The idea of a ‘classic’ is completely subjective AND can sometimes essentially be a marketing campaign by a publisher. Gah!!

      I’m glad you enjoyed this! I had a lot of fun furiously typing it all out 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree with many of your items, especially moving around genres. If you stick to one, to me, you never grow as a reader. Plus, sticking to one genre leads to possible reading slumps that last a lot longer. Who wants that?

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I agree with every point here except for no 2. I lent someone Ways to Live Forever (which I adored) and didn’t get it back. I lent someone else a book the other week which they promised to have back by a certain day, and it’s now over a week after that so I’m doubtful I’ll ever see it again! Great post xx

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Agree with many of these. Except for the lending books part–I’ve been burned too many times, and so I’m very hesitant to lend books.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I agree with you on judging others for the genre they read or putting down other genres while asking to take theirs seriously. I honestly don’t even get the logic behind that. Great post, Justine. 🙂 Especially loved the “Great Library of Justine” line! 😂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Isn’t it just so weird? We’re all readers! Why can’t we all just love each other?

      Thank you!! I think I need to start referring to my flat as ‘The Great Library of Justine’. All are welcome.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Excellent list! I’m in agreement with all of them, I just wish I weren’t so anal about book damage. I can’t stand it when my books get bent or cracked. My friends are afraid to borrow from me. I do love lending though, so I’ve even gotten in the habit of buying two copies of my favorites. That way I have one that stays pristine, and one I can lend out.

    I’m curious about this Phillipa Gregory issue. Can you point me to a link or the story?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s